The Pros and Cons of Giving Your Child a Smartphone

In today's digitally connected world, the question of when to give our children a smartphone is a common dilemma for many parents/guardians. On one hand, smartphones offer a wealth of benefits, from instant communication and access to educational resources to increased convenience in our daily lives. However, concerns about the potential negative impacts on mental health and overall wellbeing are equally significant. Some of us fear not being tech-savvy enough, some of us are tech-savvy and still fear what's out there! While yet many are just unsure of how to start off, once that phone is handed over to our kids. 

As parents/guardians, it is crucial to strike a balance and approach this decision mindfully, keeping in mind the importance of fostering healthy online habits that prioritize our children's mental health.  I strongly believe it is critical that we not speak down to parents/guardians who make the choice to give their kids phones. Everyone has different reasons for doing it. What's important is that we support each other with making the journey a successful one. In this blog post, I'll explore the pros and cons of giving your child a smartphone and how we can guide them in preserving their digital wellbeing.

The Pros:

Enhanced Communication: Smartphones enable seamless communication between parents, children, and peers. It facilitates staying in touch, providing reassurance and safety when children are away from home. Many are opting for "dumb" phones, where the only capabilities are calls (think back to our first phones). Others are using watches (although, as a teacher, these drove me crazy in the classroom as the kids were constantly checking them, or getting calls on them). It's up to you as to what you use, just remember to set guidelines around the fact that it's for communication...not passive play.

Access to Educational Resources: With smartphones, our tweens and teens can access a vast array of educational apps, online courses, and academic materials, enhancing their learning opportunities. My teens love having access to their phone in classes (hooray for tech advocate teachers who know how to mindfully integrate tech into the classroom) for uses such as scanning, documenting, recording, researching, etc. Not everyone can be tethered to a computer everywhere they go. My kiddos also enjoy watching educational videos or listening to podcasts to/from school on transport. It's a great use of time and personal development.

Increased Independence: Having a smartphone can empower children to be more independent, as they can manage tasks, schedules, and responsibilities with greater autonomy. I LOVED teaching my students how to use the calendar feature, setting reminders, important tasks, etc. Great skills to have for their future. They can also use features like "focus time" to help them understand when to work vs. play and how to avoid disruptions. And let's not forget, just having a device is a lot of responsibility, so it's a great chance to show independence and display taking care of something with collective agreements and boundaries.

Emergency Preparedness: Smartphones serve as a valuable tool for emergencies, allowing children to quickly call for help or access safety information when needed. Yes, the watches can do this too, but I find them so clunky and fidgety. Its also nice to have access to Google Maps or Maps when out and about.

The Cons:

Mental Health Concerns: Excessive screen time, especially on social media, has been linked to increased rates of anxiety, depression, and feelings of loneliness among young people. We know this, we've seen this, but I've gotta say, we're being very biased in a lot of the reports, failing to see the full story (demographics, precursors, etc). When we encounter headlines about the detrimental effects of technology on well-being, it's essential to consider the bigger picture. Many studies, including those by authoritative bodies, may carry biases or omit crucial factors that provide a more comprehensive understanding. The Surgeon General's warnings about screen time, for instance, might not account for differences in demographics, pre-existing health conditions, or unique life situations. It's like viewing a puzzle with a missing piece – you don't get the full picture.

Sleep Disruptions: The blue light emitted by screens can disrupt sleep patterns, leading to sleep deprivation and affecting children's overall wellbeing. There needs to be boundaries when it comes to this, even for adults (I still struggle with this one). Get them off before bed as best you can. The younger they are, control it, take them out of the room and set time limits. As they get older, have those conversations and show the research and data, have discussions about it, let them see the information, and come up with agreements together.

Cyberbullying and Online Safety: Smartphones provide access to the internet, making children vulnerable to cyberbullying, online predators, and exposure to inappropriate content. Yes, this is true, but again, it's not going to disappear. Now is the time to have conversations with them and navigate with them. Talk about safeguards, privacy controls, and how they can come to you if something isn't right. 

Decreased Face-to-Face Interaction: Excessive use of smartphones can lead to decreased face-to-face interactions, hindering the development of critical social skills. I'm not totally sold on this one. Does it make a valid point, yes. Do I think it's a blanket statement? Yes. Keep kids in social situations as much as possible, starting at home! Have conversations around making dinner, while eating dinner, while watching shows or doing activities. Social skills don't only come from being in a school or on a sports team. I think we miss that message when we talk about this.

Fostering Digital Wellbeing:

To support our children's mental health and foster digital wellbeing, we can implement the following strategies:

Set Screen Time Limits: Establish clear guidelines on screen time and encourage regular breaks from digital devices. Encourage offline activities, such as sports/hobbies, reading, or spending time with family and friends.

Encourage Mindful Online Behavior: Teach your children to be responsible digital citizens by promoting positive online interactions, empathy, and respect for others. Model it!

Model Healthy Tech Habits: Lead by example and demonstrate healthy tech habits yourself. Show your children the importance of balancing technology with real-life experiences.

Create Tech-Free Zones: Designate specific areas and times in the house as tech-free zones to promote family bonding and uninterrupted conversations.

Engage in Open Dialogue: Keep the lines of communication open with your children about their digital experiences. Encourage them to share any concerns or challenges they may encounter online.

As parents, we must weigh the pros and cons of giving our children a smartphone while keeping their mental health and digital wellbeing at the forefront. By fostering a healthy relationship with technology, we can empower our tweens and teens to navigate the digital world responsibly and preserve their mental health in an increasingly connected society. Let's work together to nurture their digital wellbeing and ensure that technology becomes a positive tool in their lives.

Have a tween or teen? Grab my Free parent guide!

Make sure to join my private community!